Aphid Predictions

Early season aphid activity in 2017

Prolonged exposure to low winter temperatures are known to have lethal and sub-lethal effects on populations of M. persicae which, in Scotland, overwinters in the larval stage.  Poor over-winter survival delays the build up of populations of this species in the forthcoming growing season.  Prior to 2011, SASA has used the mean temperatures for January and February to predict when M. persicae will become active in the summer.  In 2011, following an extremely cold December 2010, SASA predicted early season aphid activity have been based on the mean temperatures during the three-month period of December-February.  We intend to continue to use the model based on the three month period.

During winter 2016-17, the mean temperatures were above the mean over the last 50 years:  5.6°C at SASA (Edinburgh; mean = 4.0°C) and 5.1°C at JHI (Dundee; mean = 3.7°C).  These winter temperatures rank the 5th warmest from the last 49 years at Edinburgh and the 4th warmest from the last 51 years at Dundee.  Based on these figures, the predictions for the first flight of M. persicae is 22 May at Edinburgh (average date of first catch is 15 June) and 29 May at Dundee (average date of first catch is 16 June).  Therefore, M. persicae activity in 2017 is expected to commence 2 to 3 weeks earlier than in an average summer.

In 2016, the first M. persicae at Edinburgh was recorded on 20 June, 5 days later than the average date of first catch and 25 days later than predicted.  The first M. persicae at Dundee was recorded on 1 June, 15 days earlier than the average date and 3 days earlier than predicted.  The Dundee prediction was well within the 75% confidence limits; the reasons for the late arrival of the Edinburgh aphids are unclear.

The predictions for the Potato aphid Macrosiphum euphorbiae, Rose-Grain aphid Metopolophium dirhodum and the Grain aphid Sitobion avenae are provided by Rothamsted Research and are based on mean temperatures over January and February 2017.

Table 1

  2017 Prediction 75% Confidence Limits 2016 Obs'n

2017 Obs'n

Myzus persicae 22 May 30 April - 13 June 20 June 17 May
Macrosiphum euphorbiae 12 May 20 April - 4 June 30 May 9 May
Metopolophium dirhodum 17 May 23 April - 11 June 23 May 28 April
Sitobion avenae 20 May 29 April- 10 June 30 May 24 May
Myzus periscae 29 May 3 May - 24 June 1 June 12 May
Macrosiphum euphorbiae 23 May 28 April - 16 June 25 May 29 April
Metopolophium dirhodum 28 May 6 May - 19 June 31 May 29 April
Sitobion avenae 29 May 10 May - 17 June 9 June 16 May

The average temperatures over the 2016-17 winter indicate that the first flights of M. persicae should be 18 - 24 days earlier than the mean dates in mid-June.  Consequently, they have more potential to develop to significantly high population levels. The prediction for the total of M. persicae caught by 31 July is 41 at Edinburgh and 47 at Dundee.  The 75% confidence intervals for these predictions are 14 at the lower end and 159 at the upper for Dundee and 11 at the lower end and 151 at the upper for Edinburgh.  Therefore, populations of M. persicae could build up to significant levels during 2017. Therefore, it the potential exists for the risk of leafroll transmission to develop to high levels, particularly in crops of potato varieties that are highly susceptible.  M. persicae is also a vector of PVY but it appears that only in exceptional years do populations of this species develop within crops to such an extent as to present a risk comparable to that provided by the usually much more numerous cereal aphids. 

View archive aphid predictions